The title of this post is the title of this new article authored by Shelley Ross Saxer now on SSRN. Here is its abstract: Forfeiture laws allow law enforcement to seize property that has been used or possessed in violation...
Douglas A. Berman
Fines, Restitution and Other Economic Sanctions
Procedure and Proof at Sentencing
Sentences Reconsidered
A helpful colleague flagged for me a notable new federal district court sentence reduction opinion, US v. Cannon, No. 4:95-cr-30 (CDL), 2025 WL 326065 (MD Ga. Jan. 29, 2025). I recommend the opinion in full (though I have not found...
Douglas A. Berman
Federal Sentencing Guidelines
FIRST STEP Act and its implementation
Sentences Reconsidered
Who Sentences
As detailed in links below, this past Fall I noticed and blogged about a numbers of notable federal and state sentencings for various defendants convicted of various crimes involving animals. I was reminded of this series after seeing this local...
Douglas A. Berman
Examples of "over-punishment"
Offense Characteristics
The question in the title of this post is prompted in part by a notable opinion from last week authored by US District Judge Gary Brown in US v. Andrews, 20-CR-546 (SDNY Jan. 28, 2025) (available here). Here is a...
Douglas A. Berman
Clemency and Pardons
Procedure and Proof at Sentencing
Sentences Reconsidered
Who Sentences
The title of this post is the title of this new article authored by Paul Robinson and Hugh Rennie now available via SSRN. Here is its abstract: News accounts routinely report the sentences imposed by judges and there are commonly...
Douglas A. Berman
Prisons and prisoners
Procedure and Proof at Sentencing
Scope of Imprisonment
A helpful reader flagged an interesting concurring opinion in a case from Florida's Fifth District Court of Appeals which showcases a potental state echo from the Supreme Court's recent Sixth Amendment ruling in US v. Erlinger. At issue is application...
Douglas A. Berman
Almendarez-Torres and the prior conviction exception
Blakely in the States
Procedure and Proof at Sentencing
Who Sentences
As reported in this AP piece, "South Carolina put a third inmate to death in four months Friday as it goes through a backlog of prisoners who exhausted their appeals while the state couldn’t find lethal injection drugs." Here is...
Douglas A. Berman
Death Penalty Reforms
Yesterday, the Brennan Center for Justice published this new 10-page report titled "A Federal Agenda to Promote Safety and Justice." The report, authored by Hernandez Stroud and Rosemary Nidiry, is crafted with the Trump administration and the current Congress in...
Douglas A. Berman
Criminal justice in the Trump Administration
Prisons and prisoners
Sentences Reconsidered
Who Sentences
The title of this post is the title of this notable new paper by Ian Ayres and Fredrick E. Vars now on SSRN that includes an interesting sentencing-specific proposal. Here is the paper's abstract: Lower federal courts are struggling to...
Douglas A. Berman
Offender Characteristics
Procedure and Proof at Sentencing
Second Amendment issues
Who Sentences
The always notable Vital City has a notable and robust new special online issue titled "Crime: Looking Back at 2024, and Ahead to 2025." I count 15 pieces in the issue which all look interesting. This introductory essay provides an...
Douglas A. Berman
National and State Crime Data
As reported in this CNN piece, "[f]ormer New Jersey Democratic Sen. Bob Menendez was sentenced Wednesday to 11 years in prison following his conviction on bribery and corruption charges after taking cash, a Mercedes Benz and gold bars as bribes...
Douglas A. Berman
Celebrity sentencings
White-collar sentencing
In this post from September, I noted Adam Liptak's Sidebar column discussing federal compassionate release issues in conjunction with Judge Frederic Block's new book, "A Second Chance: A Federal Judge Decides Who Deserves It." I was pleased to see today...
Douglas A. Berman
Procedure and Proof at Sentencing
Sentences Reconsidered
Who Sentences
Pages